News
NewsOn December 5, 1945, Flight 19 embarked on a routine training mission over the Atlantic but mysteriously vanished, becoming one of the most perplexing aviation mysteries of the 20th century. This incident not only catalyzed an exhaustive search and rescue operation but also fueled speculations about the notorious Bermuda Triangle, an area reputed for the disappearance of ships and aircraft under mysterious circumstances. The significance of Flight 19 extends beyond its enigmatic disappearance; it serves as a pivotal event that continues to intrigue historians, researchers, and the public alike, compelling them to unravel what really happened on that fateful day.
This article delves into the events of December 5, 1945, dissecting the disappearance of Flight 19, the subsequent investigation into the incident, and its enduring legacy. Through examining the factual accounts and piecing together the available evidence, it aims to shed light on the circumstances that led to the loss of Flight 19 and explores the various theories that have emerged over the years. Additionally, it highlights the memorials dedicated to the lost crew, serving as a testament to their memory. By navigating the complex weave of facts and speculations, the article seeks to provide a comprehensive overview of the Flight 19 mystery and its significance within the context of the Bermuda Triangle phenomenon.
On December 5, 1945, at 14:10 hours, a squadron of five TBM Avenger torpedo bombers, known as Flight 19, took off from the U.S. Naval Air Station in Fort Lauderdale, Florida. The flight was led by Lieutenant Charles Carroll Taylor, a seasoned naval aviator with approximately 2,500 flying hours, including a combat tour in the Pacific Theater during World War II. The mission set for the day was a routine overwater navigational training flight, which was part of a standard exercise for naval aviators.
The training exercise, identified as “Navigation Problem No. 1,” was meticulously planned. The flight path was to proceed from the coast of Florida, flying east to Hen and Chickens Shoals for a low-level bombing practice, which was successfully completed around 14:30. The route was then to continue east for an additional 67 miles before turning north for 73 miles over Grand Bahama Island, and finally turning west for 120 miles to return to Fort Lauderdale. This triangular flight route was designed to test and enhance the navigational skills of the airmen through dead reckoning and timing, despite the noted absence of onboard clocks which was not considered a concern due to the assumption that each pilot had a personal watch.
As Flight 19 proceeded with their mission, the initial stages went according to plan. However, shortly after the turn north for the second leg of the journey, the situation began to deteriorate. At approximately 15:45, the Fort Lauderdale flight tower received a troubling message from Lieutenant Taylor, indicating that he was experiencing difficulty with his navigation instruments. Taylor reported both of his compasses had failed, and he expressed uncertainty about the flight’s current position. The confusion escalated as Taylor mistakenly believed they were over the Florida Keys and not the open ocean, complicating the efforts to ascertain their precise location. This communication was the beginning of a series of events that led to the ultimate disappearance of Flight 19, marking one of the most enduring mysteries in the annals of aviation.
As the afternoon progressed, the situation for Flight 19 grew increasingly dire. Initially, Lieutenant Charles C. Taylor reported trouble with his navigation instruments, leading to confusion about the squadron’s actual location. At approximately 15:45, Taylor communicated his uncertainty, stating, “Cannot see land… We seem to be off course.” This was followed by a troubling silence from the flight group. When communications resumed, it was not Taylor but another pilot’s voice expressing disorientation, noting, “We can’t find west. Everything is wrong. We can’t be sure of any direction. Everything looks strange, even the ocean.”
The last transmission from Flight 19 was particularly haunting. The pilot’s words, “It looks like we are entering white water… We’re completely lost,” marked the final communication before the squadron vanished, leaving no trace despite the clear weather conditions observed by tower personnel.
Immediately following the loss of contact with Flight 19, a large-scale search and rescue operation was launched. Two PBM Mariner flying boats, equipped with rescue gear, were dispatched to the estimated last known position of the squadron. These efforts were part of a broader operation that saw Coast Guard, Navy, and naval aviation units searching over 250,000 square miles of the Atlantic and Gulf waters. Despite these extensive efforts, the search teams found no signs of the aviators, their aircraft, or any wreckage. The operation continued relentlessly for five days, but the mystery deepened as absolutely no trace of Flight 19 or the rescue aircraft emerged.
Amidst the search for Flight 19, tragedy struck again when one of the PBM Mariner aircraft, involved in the rescue operation, disappeared. Just 20 minutes after takeoff, the aircraft, carrying 13 crew members, sent a routine communication to the base. This was the last transmission received before the aircraft vanished off radar. Later, a merchant ship reported seeing an explosion and a subsequent oil slick in the vicinity where the Mariner was last reported, suggesting a catastrophic event. It is believed that the aircraft suffered a mid-air explosion due to its notoriously unstable fuel lines, which were prone to loosening and leaking under rough conditions.
The compounded loss of both Flight 19 and the PBM Mariner rescue plane added a profound sense of urgency and somberness to the ongoing search efforts, which ultimately concluded without resolution. The incidents contributed significantly to the legend of the Bermuda Triangle, an area reputed for mysterious disappearances of ships and aircraft.
A 500-page Navy board of investigation report published a few months after the disappearance of Flight 19 made several critical observations. It was determined that the flight leader, Lt. Charles C. Taylor, had mistakenly believed that the small islands he passed over were the Florida Keys and that his flight was over the Gulf of Mexico, leading him to direct the flight northeast over the Atlantic. The report highlighted that Taylor’s compasses had failed, and he refused to switch from the training to the search and rescue radio frequency, complicating communication due to interference from Cuban radio stations. Despite these errors, the initial report did not place the blame solely on Taylor, noting that some subordinate officers likely knew their approximate position as indicated by their suggestions to fly west to reach the mainland.
The Navy’s report was later amended to “cause unknown” after Taylor’s mother contested the findings, arguing that her son was unfairly blamed without conclusive evidence such as bodies or wreckage. This amendment opened the door to various theories and speculations. Some suggested that Flight 19 had been caught in the Bermuda Triangle, an area reputed for mysterious disappearances. Others proposed more fantastical explanations, including magnetic anomalies, parallel dimensions, and even alien abductions, fueled by popular culture and movies like “Close Encounters of the Third Kind.”
The board of inquiry initially concluded that Taylor suffered from a “mental aberration” due to his confusion during the flight. However, this was contested vigorously by Taylor’s family. With legal support, they managed to get the board for the Correction of Naval Records to acknowledge that an injustice had been done to Taylor’s record. The final amendment declared that Taylor was cleared of blame and that the cause of the accident remains unknown. This unresolved conclusion leaves the story of Flight 19 open to interpretation, with the true cause of the disappearance still shrouded in mystery.
In 1989, a significant effort to commemorate Flight 19 was initiated by Walter Houghton, the Assistant Director of Fort Lauderdale Airport. Recognizing the contributions of Allan McElhiney, the founder of the NASFL Museum, Houghton secured permission to establish a Navy Park adjacent to the FAA tower on the airport’s east side. Central to this park is a memorial monument, which prominently features an original WWII propeller set against the backdrop of the tower. This monument also displays a plaque dedicated to Flight 19, originally designed by the Woman’s Council Navy League and retrieved from storage specifically for this purpose. The park was officially completed in 1990, providing a physical space for reflection and remembrance.
The Naval Air Station Fort Lauderdale Museum, now situated on a site that holds historical significance as a former naval air station, plays a crucial role in preserving the legacy of Flight 19. The museum is not only a repository of artifacts related to the infamous flight but also serves as a center for educating the public about the broader role of the base during World War II. Annually, the museum hosts memorial ceremonies that honor not only the 27 men associated with Flight 19 but also the 95 service members who perished during training exercises at the base between 1942 and 1946. The museum’s location on the National Register of Historic Places and designation as a Florida Heritage Site further underscore its importance in historical preservation.
Each year, the Naval Air Station Fort Lauderdale Museum organizes a memorial ceremony that marks the disappearance of Flight 19, an event that significantly contributed to the legend of the Bermuda Triangle. This ceremony is a poignant reminder of the 14 crewmen from the five Avenger airplanes and the 13 crewmen from the Mariner rescue seaplane, all of whom vanished on December 5, 1945. The event is open to the public and is held on the museum grounds, offering a moment of collective remembrance and honor. The ceremony not only commemorates those directly associated with Flight 19 but also celebrates the broader contributions of World War II servicemen and women, highlighting Florida’s pivotal role in military training and home front activities during the war.
Through a rigorous examination of the enigmatic disappearance of Flight 19, this article has navigated the complexities of an event that has captivated the imagination of many, weaving through historical facts, investigations, and the legacies left behind. By dissecting the series of events leading up to the disappearance, the extensive search efforts that followed, and the theories that emerged, a comprehensive overview of this mystery and its place within the larger narrative of the Bermuda Triangle phenomenon was provided. The significance of Flight 19’s story goes beyond mere speculation; it embodies a compelling chapter in aviation history that has spurred continuous inquiry and reflection.
The enduring legacy of Flight 19 is immortalized not only in the annals of unsolved mysteries but also through the memorials and commemorative efforts that seek to honor the memory of those lost. The establishment of monuments and the annual memorials conducted by the Naval Air Station Fort Lauderdale Museum serve as a testament to the lives intertwined with this mysterious event, ensuring their stories persist in our collective memory. As the article concludes, it leaves readers with a sense of the profound impact that Flight 19 has had on historical, cultural, and scientific dialogues, encouraging ongoing exploration and remembrance of one of aviation’s most enduring mysteries.
